Media Supports Demonizing of Trans Children, Silent on Trans Reparative Therapy
April 9, 2015
Repeating the cycle at MichFest: The clash of two feminisms
April 12, 2015

TransAdvocate Suspending Its MichFest Petition Signature

By Autumn Sandeen
@AutumnSandeen

 

On the evening of April 8, 2015, The TransAdvocate editors came to a unanimous decision to suspend our signature on the Equality Michigan petition asking for MichFest to change their trans exclusionary, womyn-born-womyn intention.

This was decided after earlier in the day the National Center for Lesbian Rights’ (NCLR’s) Kate Kendall sent a letter to Lisa Vogel and withdrew its name from Equality Michigan’s petition asking for MichFest to change its trans exclusionary, womyn-born-womyn intention.

Thumbnail Link: copy of NCLR's Kate Kendall's Letter To MichFest's Lisa Vogel, Dated April 8, 2015

Copy of NCLR’s Kate Kendall’s Letter To MichFest’s Lisa Vogel, Dated April 8, 2015

Dear Lisa,

As you know, last summer NCLR signed the petition sponsored by Equality Michigan calling on the organizers of the Michigan Womyn’s Music Festival (Michfest) to embrace the presence of transgender women at the iconic gathering. In the wake of our signing, you contacted us to express your disappointment and anger that NCLR would sign a petition which called for a boycott of the festival.

Many of the letters we received recognized transgender women as women and sisters in struggle, while also arguing that the intention of Michfest does not diminish the lived experience of transgender women.

Since then, we have been involved in a number of conversations with Michfest womyn, Equality Michigan, transgender leaders and colleagues who signed the petition. These conversations have made clear that there are essential values and perspectives we all share and that the petition was not going to be an effective vehicle for a resolution.

NCLR has removed our name from the petition and will be actively engaged in conversations in which we honor our differences while also pursuing a conclusion that supports the gender identity and inclusion of all women in Michfest. We have faith that such a resolution is possible.

This entire process has been one of great learning for me and, while we may disagree on some issues, I think there are many values we share. I signed the petition on behalf of NCLR because our core passion and commitment is that we all be able to live fully and be embraced as our authentic selves.

We are grounded in some deeply held principles, including the belief that discrimination and bigotry against lesbians is rooted in sexism, misogyny and the devaluation of women. We do not believe it is possible to win liberation for lesbians in a world where misogyny thrives. We also do not believe we can end the oppression of women and lesbians in a world where transgender women are reviled and targeted.

NCLR has come to a deeper understanding of what Michfest means to our community and seeks to honor that through this process. We also acknowledge the Michfest organizers have been involved in an ongoing conversation over the years on this issue. We are committed to honest and forthright dialogue as a more constructive means for seeking resolution and common ground.

Sincerely,

Kate

On April 10th, the LGBTQ Task Force followed suit with its own e-letter regarding pulling its signature from the MichFest petition.

LGBTQ Task Force’s Rea Carey’s E-letter To LGBTQ Community Regarding MichFest Petition, dated April 10, 2015

Greetings,

Last year, the National LGBTQ Task Force signed onto a petition organized by Equality Michigan which called upon the Michigan Womyn’s Music Festival (Michfest) to fully welcome and include transgender women, as women, at the festival.

You took the time to write to me and I appreciate that you did – you and others shared with me your perspectives and experiences on the land that some described as “sacred,” “an annual touchstone,” iconic” and “home.” I heard that you are angry and hurt by the Task Force and other organizations signing the petition. I heard from you and others that Michfest is a truly historic and transformative annual event that has influenced, inspired and helped to liberate millions of womyn/women from the daily trials and tribulations of misogyny and sexism. It holds a very special place in the hearts of lesbians and other womyn/women.

In the months between then and now, I have talked with womyn/women who have attended, womyn/women who would like to attend, and other people who have a variety of views. I’ve talked with our colleagues at Equality Michigan, leaders of other organizations who have been engaged in this, and with transgender women. From these conversations, I have gleaned shared values, differing opinions, and have come to a view that in order to move forward in any type of dialogue we must move beyond the petition.

I am writing to let you know that the Task Force has asked that our name be removed from the Equality Michigan petition and we will be seeking other ways to be in dialogue about Michfest’s intention regarding transgender women. As we reflected on the petition’s contents and read carefully letters from concerned people like you, we came to understand that the point in the original petition that called for a boycott of vendors and performers was misaligned with our own support for womyn/women artists, craftspeople and musicians. Although that point was withdrawn from the petition, we recognize and share the deep concern about the possible economic impact on womyn/women striving every day to make a living through their art, craft and music.

Please know that the Task Force’s view regarding the MichFest intention is rooted in our core value of inclusiveness and the festival’s extraordinary transformative power. For over 40 years, the Task Force has worked for the full inclusion of lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and queer identified people in all areas of our lives – whether it be in the workplace, the government, companies and, yes, in our own community.

The Task Force will remain in active discussion with MichFest womyn/women, Equality Michigan, transgender colleagues, and other organizations that signed the petition. The Task Force is committed to productive discussions in which we honor our differences and also pursue our desire for MichFest to fully welcome the gender identities of all womyn/women at the festival, including transgender women.

For over 40 years, the Task Force has worked for a changed world. A world in which we can all experience liberation. A world in which misogyny cannot thrive. A world in which womyn/women, lesbians, bisexual women and transgender women no longer experience sexism, targeted attacks and the most horrible form of violence – murder. As we intensify our work to take on all of the challenges we face as a movement, know that these values are at the heart of what we do.

With care and in solidarity,

Rea

On April 10th, I called Emily Dievendorf, the Executive Director of Equality Michigan, and informed her of our decision to suspend our participation in the petition in an attempt to foster the kind of honest and forthright dialogue that Kate Kendall suggests; we are committed to the truly productive discussions that Rea Carey states are necessary. These kinds of discussions cannot be done with intermediaries alone.

In the past weeks, we in the United States saw that direct, honest and forthright dialogue with representatives of Iran brought an agreement with Iran, a country that our nation has had poor relations with since the 1970s. Much of trans community has endured poor relations with MichFest leadership since the 1970s, and it’s time for similar direct honest and forthright dialogue between representatives of trans community and MichFest organizers towards truly productive discussions.

We at The TransAdvocate know that this type of dialogue was suggested to the organizers at MichFest last year and the idea was rejected; we have had an intermediary reach out and suggest the same for this year. We have the urgency of now.

It would be too easy for Lisa Vogel to say that there is only four months until the next MichFest, so there is insufficient time to work this out before the next MichFest. This is simply untrue.

Lisa knows trans womyn have attended MichFest for many years — trans womyn who identify themselves as womyn-born-womyn. She doesn’t have to change the change the womyn-born-womyn intention, she just needs to say “Trans womyn who identify as womyn-born-womyn are welcome at MichFest.”

Lisa already acknowledges that trans womyn are womyn. So, it’s just a small step forward to meet with a number of us, and another small step forward to acknowledge that trans womyn who identify as womyn-born-womyn are welcome at MichFest.

To paraphrase Alice Paul, our women’s movement — our womyn’s movement — is a sort of mosaic. Each of us puts in one little stone, and then in the end you get a great mosaic. Trans women — trans womyn who identify as womyn-born-womyn — are needed at MichFest to bring our stones for the great mosaic. If we can never, by intention, never openly bring our stones, then that mosaic will never truly be complete.

We at the TransAdvocate are making a good-faith effort to engage MichFest in dialogue with the goal of a reconciliation that will bring an end to the decades of trauma the MichFest, trans and feminist communities have experianced. So, we at The TransAdvocate are giving pause; we’re giving space. We’re giving space to give an opportunity for the face-to-face meetings that are long overdue to reconcile, heal, and embrace the core value of inclusiveness. We, along with MichFest associated intermediaties who are in dialogue with the TransAdvocate, have reached out to Vogel and await a response.


Tip this TransAdvocate!

Writers for the TransAdvocate work hard to bring you news and commentary. If you found this article meaningful, let the author know that you appreciate the work they do with a tip!
TipJar
  • Pingback: This Year’s Michigan Womyn’s Music Festival Will Be the Last – Advocate.com | Portable audio shop()

  • Amalthea

    Personally I am commenting to reaffirm my support of the Equality Michigan petition, which in no way prevents good faith negotiations for a more inclusive Michfest. However, the petition does express a clear moral position that an exclusive “intention” is exactly that until words and actions affirm that indeed the situation has changed.

    Here I have a special responsibility, because, having signed the petition, I saw the Michfest statement of August 18 as a possible step toward peace with justice. For 11 weeks, I took part in internal dialogues which, if conducted with determination and right intent on all sides, could have speedily resolved the main issues behind the boycott and set the stage for an inclusive and Lesbian-centered Michfest 40.

    The short story is that by the end of August, it had become clear to me that the leaders of the process wished to keep it centered, not on the August 18 statement with its language affirming that “trans women” can and do attend and volunteer at Michfest as “supporters of, rather than detractors from, our female-focused culture,” but rather on the intention itself for “womyn born female” or WBF only.

    And, above all, I did not see any will on the part of the leadership to repudiate or discourage the kind of freelance gender policing that seeks to discourage trans women, many Lesbian, from attending by describing such attendees as “gatecrashers,” or “violators,” or even comparable to male rapists simply by being present in women’s space.

    In the days after the August 18 statement, I sought to do my part to smooth the way to a genuine peace by trying to understand Lisa Vogel’s position at different points in this long conflict, and seek language that could affirm Michfest’s welcome to all women while leaving room for different ideological viewpoints that were obviously not going to disappear.

    Looking back, I cannot even begin to explain the August 18 statement except as a strictly legalistic defense that Michfest, literally speaking, does not actually deny any woman a ticket, and therefore is not involved in the narrowest definition of “discrimination.” This has been true since 2006, but with a proviso that I incorrectly read the August 18 as finally and decisively moving beyond: the famous disclaimer of August 25, 2006 that if a trans woman “purchased a ticket, it represents nothing more than that womon choosing to disrespect the stated intention of this Festival.”

    If that was in fact the intended reading of the August 18 statement, then it could have and should have been written differently, sparing me and others what proved to be the experience of a largely futile exercise in “dialogue.” It might simply and frankly been stated that Michfest will refuse no woman a ticket, but that many women attending do in fact regard trans women as “boundary violators,” and also believe that any trans woman with the least bit of respect for the event would not attend.

    What I also find it vital to emphasize are the hospitable intentions of many women who attend Michfest and would like an inclusive policy which, at the same time, affirms the many valuable traditions of Festival. The Michfest leadership could have inaugurated a new era for Fest, while doing justice to many attendees of good will, by guiding the dialogue process to a generous implementation of the inclusion promised by the August 18 statement. What I saw happen was, regrettably, quite different.

    Finally, in continuing my support for the Equality Michigan petition, I would like to emphasize that my own endorsement of the boycott in no way seeks nor should be taken to disparage the courageous efforts of those Lesbians (binary and nonbinary) who are continuing to attend Festival in order to provide lifegiving support for trans women who wish to attend and enjoy what should be and often is a space of sisterly healing and mutual affirmation.

  • Pingback: TransAdvocate Suspending Its MichFest Petition Signature | The TransAdvocate |()

  • Sami

    What a steaming load of bullshit. Lisa Vogel does not acknowledge us as women. That’s just a bit of doublespeak she uses to try to paint herself as trans friendly while still labeling us males. You know as well as I do that seperating women from female is just a rhetorical trick to hide their bigotry behind a facade of acceptance. They get to claim to be friendly to trans women while gleefully bashing us as males who will never ever be real females like them. She accepts us as ‘women’ in the same way groups like the FRC ‘love’ us, as paper thin veil behind which they hide their utter contempt for our existence.

    Shame on you for buying into her lies. This’ll be the last comment I ever leave on this site. I will no longer visit or in any way support a site that grovels to bigots.

    If she actually does come out welcoming us as females, real females just as female as she is, than I’ll return and admit I was wrong. However I’m pretty damn certain I won’t have to.

  • Jane

    Well, to no surprise at all, another organization, one under the guise of being “Trans Advocates”, turns their back on the trans community. After “decades of Trauma” do you really think Michfest deserves a “good faith effort”? This is a complete and udder joke. Bye TransAdvocate.