Revisiting ‘the fallacy of cis privilege, again.’

I’ve noticed that TERFs tend to lie. Like, a lot. As in, metric tons of BS.

TERFs far and wide are currently gnashing their collective teeth over the reality that their hate-fest conference (#RadFem2013) was booted from its venue for the second year in a row. Instead of being an emotional adult about their situation, they instead (of course) chose to construct a narrative wherein their bad behavior had nothing to do with their eviction; instead, they’re victims of a conspiracy. In other words, they all chosen to collectively lie about what happened.

I recently saw this TERF tweet about the ‘fallacy of cis privilege’ and thought I’d check out. The tweet linked to an archive.org post which opines about the non-existence of cis privilege:

Let’s play a quick game. Which do you think the self-identified RadFem did to disprove cis privilege? Did she…

A.) Honestly discuss and review the issues and offer evidence-based critiques?

B.) Present a fallacious argument and lie about the trans experience in a puerile attempt of PWNage?

Actually, the answer is A!

She offered an amazingly insightful critique of post-modern… No, I’m fuckn’ with ya. It’s B. Of course it’s B:

genderbox

Source: Archive.com

Before I get into deconstructing this RadFem lie, let’s review definitions (cuz TERFs luv them some word games!):

Gender is a generic term we use to refer to any/all aspects of gender orientation, gender identity and gender expression:

gender-orientation

Gender Orientation refers to one’s subjective experience of one’s physical sex. Gender Identity refers to one’s subjective experience of a cultural sex. Gender Expression refers to one’s subjective experience of communicating gender orientation and identity. Taken together, these three dimensions of gender are the subjective result of the brain’s neurology within the context of a society’s culture.

One’s gender orientation might be male, while their gender identity could be female even though their gender expression is androgynous.  Gender is, in fact, multi-dimensional and not all of these dimensions are always aligned. (e.g., third gender)

When we talk about gender, we’re talking about these three dimensions. When someone says that their gender is hard-wired, they’re saying that they have an innate sense of their physical sex.Note 1

Transgender (AKA: trans, trans*, TG) is an umbrella term that encompasses a variety of people including transsexuals, crossdressers, drag kings and queens, as well as bigender and androgynous individuals.1 Transgender that came into common usage during the 1970s, but was popularized as early as 1965 as a way to refer to transsexuals who wanted genital reconstructive surgery. Today, the term transgender is used to refer to individuals who are not cisgender.

Cisgender (AKA: Cis, cissexual) is an umbrella term that encompasses a variety of people who are not transgender. For example, this term is used to refer to someone who was sexed male at birth, subjectively experiences their sex to be male, identifies as a male and expresses his identity in a manner consistent with a generally accepted cultural male gender role.

Cis-Privilege (AKA, transphobia, heterosexism, cisgenderism) refers to a set of unearned advantages that individuals who identify as the gender they were assigned at birth accrue solely due to being cisgender.2

Cisgenderism instills shame in trans individuals, causing them to internalize transphobia that is directed toward them by society.3 Some trans individuals learn to devalue themselves and value only cisgender persons instead. The negative effects of cisgenderism include the following:

  • Self-blame for the victimization one has suffered
  • A negative self-concept as a result of negative messages about trans issues
  • Anger directed inward resulting in destructive patterns such as substance abuse
  • A victim mentality or feelings of inadequacy, helplessness  and despair that interfere with leading a fulfilling life
  • Self-victimization that may hinder emotional growth and development.

Examples of cis-privilege as reported by the trans community:

  1. You can use public restrooms without fear of verbal abuse, physical intimidation, or arrest.
  2. Strangers don’t assume they can ask you what your genitals look like and how you have sex.
  3. If you are murdered (or have any crime committed against you), your gender expression will not be used as a justification for your murder (“gay panic”) nor as a reason to coddle the perpetrators.
  4. You have the ability to walk through the world and generally blend-in, not being constantly stared or gawked at, whispered about, pointed at, or laughed at because of your gender expression.
  5. Strangers call you by the name you provide, and don’t ask what your “real name” [birth name] is and then assume that they have a right to call you by that name.
  6. You have the ability to flirt, engage in courtship, or form a relationship and not fear that your biological status may be cause for rejection or attack, nor will it cause your partner to question their sexual orientation.
  7. If you end up in the emergency room, you do not have to worry that your gender will keep you from receiving appropriate treatment, or that all of your medical issues will be seen as a result of your gender.
  8. Your identity is not considered a mental pathology (“gender identity disorder” in the DSM IV) by the psychological and medical establishments.
  9. You are not required to undergo an extensive psychological evaluation in order to receive basic medical care.
  10. [You are] able to assume that everyone you encounter will understand your identity, and not think you’re confused, misled, or hell-bound when you reveal it to them.

Studies show that the trans population lives under extreme psychological pressures unseen in even active military personnel. Fifty-five percent of trans people 4,5 were found to live with social anxiety. Within the general American population, similar types of anxiety are experienced by only 6.8% of the population while these levels of anxiety were found to exist at a rate of 8.2% among military personal.6

chart

Levels of social anxiety experienced by population.

If you, by virtue of being not trans don’t deal with this level of anxiety as a population, that’s a privilege you enjoy. If you don’t have to deal with the following realities because you’re not trans, that’s a fucking privilege:

Gender variant and transgender individuals must cope with multiple unique challenges, including significant discrimination, prejudice, and the potential for victimization from violent hate crimes. They often experience discrimination when accessing health care and are denied numerous basic civil rights and protections… transgender and gender variant people are frequently denied medical, surgical, and psychiatric care related to gender transition. Access to medical care (both medical and surgical) positively impacts the mental health of transgender and gender variant individuals.

Being transgender or gender variant implies no impairment in judgment, stability, reliability, or general social or vocational capabilities; however, these individuals often experience discrimination due to a lack of civil rights protections for their gender identity or expression. Transgender and gender variant persons are frequently harassed and discriminated against when seeking housing or applying for jobs or schools, are often victims of violent hate crimes, and face challenges in marriage, adoption, and parenting rights.

Discrimination and lack of equal civil rights is damaging to the mental health of transgender and gender variant individuals. For example, gender-based discrimination and victimization were found to be independently associated with attempted suicide in a population of transgender individuals, 32% of whom had histories of trying to kill themselves, and in the largest survey to date of gender variant and transgender people 41% reported attempting suicide.*

The APA joins other organizations, including the American Medical Association and the American Psychological Association, in endorsing strong policy statements deploring the discrimination experienced by gender variant and transgender individuals and calling for laws to protect their civil rights.

– The American Psychiatric Association, 8/16/12, Release No. 12-36

If you don’t have to deal with the following simply because you’re not trans, that’s a fucking privilege:

I have spent so many hours avoiding public multi-stall bathrooms that I have damaged my bladder and put pressure on my kidneys. The problem was a daily one. I’d think about where I was going what bathrooms I’d have access to, how much I drank during the day, whether I’d be with people who could help stand guard…

–  Response to a 2002 survey conducted by the San Francisco Human Rights Commission which found that nearly 50% of transgender respondents reported harassment or assault when simply attempting to use a public bathroom

We live under the constant threat of horrifying violence. We have to worry about what bathroom to use when our bladders are aching. We are forced to consider whether we’ll be dragged out of a bathroom and arrested or face a fist fight while our bladders are still aching .  It’s an everyday reality for us. Human beings must use toilets… If I go into the women’s bathroom, am I prepared for the shouting and shaming? Will someone call security or the cops? If I use the men’s room, am I willing to fight my way out? Am I really ready for the violence that could ensue?

– Leslie Feinberg, Trans Liberation: Beyond Pink or Blue, p 68 – 69

Note, that the jackass who created the image RadFems are bandying about as if it were an accurate representation of the trans experience ends their strawman comic with, “Trans or not, one is not privileged for being forced into the fem gender crate from birth. IT’S THE FUCKING OPPOSITE OF PRIVILEGE.

This seems to be a beloved (fallacious) argument for RadFems.  The other day I tried to reason with a RadFem about what cis privilege means, and she (of course) simply asserted that there’s no such thing a cis privilege because cis women can’t get abortions in other countries. In both cases, the argument they’re making is “Oppression Olympics. There is no cis privilege.”

c2

Oppression Olympics FTW!

If you’re going to assert that you don’t enjoy an unearned advantage by virtue of your status as a non-trans person, you’re going to need to explain the health, housing, murder, rape, assault and employment disparities between trans and cis people with something other than a strawman or an infinite regression argument. Note 2

Also, asserting that “Trans people” (as if it were some monolithic group)  are burning to collectively jump into the other one of only two binary cultural gender boxes is a lie.  There’s a huge portion of the trans population that’s not interested in jumping from one binary to the other. Some transmen are butch, some aren’t; some transwomen are fem; some aren’t; some trans people are neither and/or both (and every fucking point from top to bottom and side to side). But, I suppose that reality isn’t convenient for the RadFem version of the trans experience they’ve presented to support their assertion that there is no cis privilege.

TERFs have been making the same vapid assertions and arguments for decades. They hunted and outed trans folk to their employers in the hope of ending careers. They worked with known racists to shut down access to health care for trans folk and then lobbied two US administrations to institute a national program of forced reparative therapy for trans folk. TERF leaders asserted that trans folk should be legislated out of existence. TERFs can and do stand in opposition to trans equality laws and even recently asked that the UN remove trans protections from the books. TERFs killed Filisa Vistima with the exact same poison which is publicly defended, cultivated and spread via the events like RadFem2013.

So, by way of summation, an excerpt from Cesaire:

… Lying is your trademark.
And you have lied so much to me
(lied about the world, lied about me)
that you have ended by imposing on me
an image of myself.
underdeveloped, you brand me, inferior,
That is the way you have forced me to see myself
I detest that image! What’s more, it’s a lie!
But now I know you, you old cancer,
and I know myself as well


NOTE 1: Another game RadFems play is called equivocation. In the trans community, when one talks about “gender identity,” they may be referring to what I call gender orientation or they may be referring to the way in which one might refer to their subjective experience of a cultural sex or they may be talking about both. When a trans person talks about gender identity as it relates to their subjective experience of their body’s sex, RadFems generally attack that narrative by pretending that the trans person was instead referring to their cultural sex designation.  I’m therefore using  language that won’t support the RadFem language games they like to play.

NOTE 2: An example of the RadFem  infinite regression argument is when a RadFem asserts that cis privilege isn’t the problem because the real problem is the patriarchy. According to this regression argument, one cannot assert the proposition of privilege because such an assertion requires a secondary cause. However, playing the rhetorical back-a-step game can be played forever.  This means that any proposition whatsoever can be endlessly (infinitely) questioned, like a child who asks “why?” over and over again:

Trans Person: The reason trans folk experience disparities is cis privilege.

An Asshole: Nope, the reason trans folk experience disparities is patriarchy which manifests as disparities. On 2nd thought, the reason trans folk experience disparities is a lack of critically analyzing the manifestation patriarchy, which supports patriarchy, which manifests as disparities. On 3rd thought, the reason trans folk experience disparities is a lack of open mindedness to critically analyzing the manifestation patriarchy, which supports patriarchy, which manifests as disparities. On 4th thought, the reason trans folk experience disparities is a lack of compassion which leads to a lack of open mindedness which leads to a lack of critically analyzing the manifestation patriarchy, which supports patriarchy, which manifests as disparities. On 5th thought, etc… ad infinitum.

No, the issue is that assholes keep clinging to bullshit ideas about trans people because, hey… trans people don’t know what the fuck they’re talking about anyway! And BTW, STFU about disparities and cis privilege and justify your lived experience to me because it’s not valid until I say so!

Tweet from an organizer of RadFem 2013

Tweet from an organizer of RadFem 2013

  1. Richard Tewksbury. & Patricia Gagné, (1996). Transgenderists: Products of non-normative intersections of sex, gender and sexuality. Journal of Men’s Studies, 105-129.
  2. Walls, N. E., & Costello, K. (2010). “Head ladies center for teacup chain”: Cisgender privilege in a (predominantly) gay male context. In S. Anderson & V. Middleton, (Eds.) Explorations in Privilege, Oppression, & Diversity (2nd Edition), pp. 81-93. Belmont, CA: BrooksCole.
  3. Neisen, Joseph H. (1990). “Heterosexism: Redefining homophobia for the 1990s” in JOURNAL OF GAY AND LESBIAN PSYCHOTHERAPY, 1, 3. 21-35.
  4. Kenagy, G., & Bostwick, W. (2005). The health and social service needs of transgender people in Chicago. International Journal of Transgenderism, 8(2/3), 57-66.
  5. Padgett, P., & Risser, J. (2010).Transgender HIV behavioral survey (thbs): Pilot study in Houston, TX. Unpublished manuscript, School of Public Health , The University of Texas, Houston, Texas.
  6. Social anxiety disorder and social fears in the Canadian military: Prevalence, comorbidity, impairment, and treatment-seeking, Journal of Psychiatric Research, Volume 44, Issue 14, October 2010, Pages 887–893

[alert type=”info”]Cross-posted from Ehipassiko[/alert]

wonka

3 Comments

  1. Pingback: hardcorps80204 (@hardcorps80204) April 27, 2013
  2. Pingback: @Tontonberry April 27, 2013
  3. Pingback: Jemima101 (@itsjustahobby) April 27, 2013
  4. Pingback: Alice (@Artemissian) April 27, 2013
  5. Pingback: @Kyammix April 27, 2013
  6. Pingback: @Persecuted23 April 27, 2013
  7. Correctrix June 1, 2013
  8. CathyL2 March 29, 2014
  9. skip hire Watford July 20, 2014

Add Comment

img_5800e5bd88d8a
Johns Hopkins Resumes Trans Care
DL-art
The New York Magazine lies to parents about trans children
92
The media is lying about why NC is being sued
91
What the US Attorney General actually said about trans people & fighting NC in court
transphobia5
The Politics of Transphobia
img_579a295a28d15
Is Sadism Popular With TERFs? A Chat With An Ex-Gendercrit
chai
EEOC Commissioner: “Contrary state or local laws provide no defense to an employer that violates Title VII”
85
Study: Trans kid’s gender implicit; govt report condemns conversion therapy
95c
The Gill Foundation & NCTE choose money over trans lives
KrellTitle
In Memory of Terri Williams Moore (1941–1976)
87
[Updated] Predatory publishers and their dupes
84
The NY Times goes concern trolling
95c
The Gill Foundation & NCTE choose money over trans lives
transphobia5
The Politics of Transphobia
86
Fight back: Report Mississippi & North Carolina HATE here!
CitizensForResponsiblePolicy_CreepyGuy
The 2008 Gainesville Bathroom Bill TV Spot Revisited