Is Criticism of Marriage Equality a Sign of Homophobia in the Trans Community?
June 27, 2015
I’m Trans, and I Don’t Like or Use the Trans Flag
July 5, 2015

In Case You Missed it, Hillary Clinton Can’t Say Transgender

I’m not sure why the Hillary Clinton campaign is sending me their LGBT related emails (I’ve never solicited this), but it seems as if I’ve been put on her press list. Today I received this:

Screenshot_2015-06-29-20-15-22

It’s an email from the Clinton campaign, reminding us that Clinton is the candidate best suited to tackle “LGBT” rights. In case the campaign needs a lesson on what the LGBT acronym means:

  • L is for lesbian
  • G is for gay
  • B is for bisexual
  • T is for transgender

The post the Clinton campaign is promoting is from long time Clinton supporter, Bruce Cohen. Cohen starts off well:

“June is Pride month. It’s a time to celebrate the impact that our brothers and sisters in the LGBTQ community have on this world. This time is also a constant reminder for me and my husband, Gabe, of the friends we have lost over the years and all the work that still needs to be done to ensure that each and every one of us has the opportunity to live our lives free from discrimination.”

Cohen includes the Q in his piece. This piece is going to be the most progressive LGBT campaign post ever! Right?

“Hillary has fought for LGBTQ rights, called for an end to discrimination based on sexual orientation, and worked tirelessly to ensure that everyone has the opportunity to fulfill their potential in this world.” [emphasis added]

I spy, with my T person eye, a key phrase missing from the sentence. Gender identity isn’t mentioned at all. Maybe Cohen will correct his mistake?

“Almost 25 years ago, Hillary Clinton met with some of my friends at AIDS Project Los Angeles, many of whom were suffering from HIV/AIDS. Hillary was one of the few public figures at the time to join our community in the fight against the spread of that deadly disease. Since then, I have followed her career as a public official and have watched her tackle issues that most politicians have long ignored.”

Hmmmmm, what issue have most politicians ignored, even in the “LGBT” policy arena? This isn’t the first time I’ve documented Hillary Clinton’s silence on transgender rights. In the 2008 campaign Clinton said very little about supporting “gender identity” in legislation, much less her campaign’s inclusion of transgender rights. Cohen opines:

“In the Senate, Hillary fought to lift restrictions that blocked gay and lesbian couples from adopting children, she spoke out against “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell,” and she repeatedly called for passage of the Employment Non-Discrimination Act to prevent discrimination based on sexual orientation in the workplace.” [emphasis added]

Oh gender identity, wherefore art thou, gender identity?

In 2008 the former Human Rights Campaign transgender board member, Donna Rose, said on her blog:

“It’s nice to see that some of our input finally seems to be sinking in although I’d be remiss if I didn’t share that a large group of LGBT steering committee supporters is floating a string of emails in the background recommending that she use the term “gay and lesbian” instead of GLBT when talking to broader audiences. Needless to say, I’m not on board with any terminology that leaves us out.”

If this post that is put forth by the Clinton campaign is any indication, that recommendation is still force. Cohen continues:

During her time at the State Department, Hillary Clinton made history as an advocate for the LGBTQ community, not just here in America, but throughout the world. At a speech in Geneva, Switzerland to celebrate International Human Rights Day, Hillary made a bold declaration that showed us in the gay community and leaders all over the world her true dedication to the cause: “Gay rights are human rights, and human rights are gay rights.” Those words may seem simple, but they were historic and had a profound impact on me and the LGBTQ community, and they will continue to do so for years to come.

It’s important to note that both this statement and the State Department’s change in trans passport regulations happened under the Obama administration. As I’ve stated before, Obama has been a “fierce advocate” for transgender people and that advocacy goes all the way back to Illinois with his sponsorship of SB2597 that amended the Illinois Human Rights act to include gender identity and sexual orientation. Clinton has no such bonafides outside her time at the State Department under the Obama administration.

Cohen ends with:

“There is no doubt in my mind that Hillary Clinton will build a better future for all Americans, free from discrimination and prejudice. That’s why I’m supporting her for president.”

There’s certainly doubt in my mind. In 2008 Vanessa Edwards Foster put it this way:

“One thing that is for certain: a vote for Sen. Clinton may as well be a vote for HRC and it’s incremental and non-egalitarian approach to equality.”

From the sound of Cohen’s post, the song remains the same.

15 Comments

  1. margaret b. says:

    Hey Marti! Hope you’re happy about having trashed Clinton….good luck with the fallout of your snatchy bitching about the ONLY person who stood to give trans any protections at all. But, then again, you probably aren’t 15 and in high school facing the shit coming down on young kids who don’t have the position and choices that you do. Nice work.

  2. It is amazing watching LGBT community giving up their citizenship to become lobbyist of it’s own agenda.
    The world and what is better for US citizens don’t matter.
    Of course the community has to fight of it’s right but as being part of humanity and not as lobbyists.

  3. Justin Michael says:

    There is no other politician or political figure in history who has championed and implemented more pro-LGBT legislation. Shame on anyone who is too damn lazy to research the FACTS, instead content to wallow in willful stupidity and be an irrelevant mouthpiece. #Pathetic

  4. Justin Michael says:

    Lesbian, gay, bisexual, and TRANSGENDER Americans deserve to live their lives free from discrimination.

    Hillary will:
    https://www.hillaryclinton.com/issues/lgbt-equality/

    Fighting for Full Equality for LGBT People
    https://www.hillaryclinton.com/briefing/factsheets/2015/12/17/fighting-for-full-equality/

    How Hillary Clinton Moved Trans Rights Forward
    http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2016/03/24/how-hillary-clinton-moved-trans-rights-forward.html

    10 Promises Hillary Clinton Just Made to LGBT Americans
    http://www.advocate.com/election/2015/10/06/10-promises-hillary-clinton-just-made-lgbt-americans

    Transgender Community Rallies in Support of Hillary Clinton
    http://www.hrc.org/blog/transgender-community-rallies-in-support-of-hillary-clinton

    Meet 12 transgender Americans who are proud to support Hillary Clinton.
    https://www.hillaryclinton.com/feed/meet-12-transgender-americans-who-are-proud-support-hillary-clinton/

  5. Justin Michael says:

    “I’m very pleased I could be here [in 2000] to march with so many friends and supporters on behalf of gay rights,” said #Clinton
    http://nypost.com/2000/06/26/raucous-fun-fills-5th-ave-at-gay-parade/

    “#NewYork Mayor Rudolph W. Giuliani (R) and Senate candidate #HillaryRodhamClinton (D) marched in New York #Pride #Parade.

    Supporters Hillary Clinton shouted “You look gorgeous” and “We love you” as the #FirstLady joined the parade accompanied by state and local officials. She marched 20 paces behind a man in a pink tutu and a skater wearing nothing but a thong. She gave the thumbs-up sign and clapped her hands to the disco music.”
    https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/2000/06/26/hillary-clinton-giuliani-march-in-ny-gay-parade/93eab33a-6e64-4c3b-9035-f8dbd1a2e30e/

    http://www.cbsnews.com/news/gay-marches-coast-to-coast/

  6. Justin Michael says:

    “Hillary Clinton was the force behind a little-known breakthrough in transgender rights. So why doesn’t she talk about it?”
    http://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2016/07/hillary-clinton-2016-transgender-rights-passport-policy-state-department-lgbt-equality-214007

  7. Justin Michael says:

    “Hillary Clinton rarely takes credit for this major transgender victory…”
    http://www.lgbtqnation.com/2016/07/hillary-clinton-rarely-takes-credit-major-transgender-victory/

  8. Anna Nguyen says:

    I don’t believe anything said here. There is no reference or proof. Certainly, a search for “hillary clinton on transgender rights” returns this link: http://www.transequality.org/blog/hillary-clinton-talks-about-transgender-rights-on-nprs-fresh-air

    I welcome any reference showing that it was Obama who was responsible for the passport gender policy changes.

  9. Jenny Fromdablock says:

    Protect transgender rights. We must do more to end discrimination against the transgender community. Hillary believes no one should be held back from fully participating in our society because of their gender identity. As secretary of state, Hillary made it possible for transgender Americans to have their true identity reflected on their passports. As president, she will work to protect transgender individuals from violence by directing the government to collect better data regarding crime victims and seeking to improve reporting of hate crimes; streamline identity documents to remove barriers to transgender Americans changing their gender marker on identification documents; and invest in law enforcement training focused on fair and impartial policing, including in interactions with LGBT individuals. Hillary will invest in law enforcement training that focuses on issues such as implicit bias, use of force, and de-escalation, as well as fair and impartial policing including in their interactions with the LGBT community, in particular transgender individuals. It will also focus on educating police officers on correctly identifying bias-motivated crimes.

    That’s a quote from Hillary’s website. You’re wrong, now stop it.

    • Truth McTrutherson says:

      The passport change is literally mentioned in the article and they are right, it was Obama, not Hillary that pushed it. Hillary has a history of claiming great deeds that happened during her time as secretary, even if she had little to do with them.

Leave a comment