Radical Feminists on the Transgender v. HBS Controversy

I found a pretty intriguing comment over at Womens Spaces/The Margins concerning a post written by Harry Benjamin Syndrome apologist, Cathy Platine, at Pam’s House Blend.

That whole thread over at PHB consists of males scratching out turf over the female body, each laying claim to ownership.

While I live in this society as a woman, the reality is that I’m male bodied and a surgically constructed vagina will not change that.

Thoughts?

493 Comments

  1. Stellewriter January 29, 2008
  2. Stellewriter January 29, 2008
  3. Sue January 29, 2008
  4. Sue January 29, 2008
  5. Laura_Mac January 29, 2008
    • leigh February 1, 2008
  6. Sue January 29, 2008
  7. Val January 29, 2008
  8. Sue January 29, 2008
  9. Laura_Mac January 29, 2008
  10. Laura_Mac January 29, 2008
  11. Laura_Mac January 29, 2008
  12. Val January 29, 2008
  13. Tobi January 29, 2008
  14. Les January 29, 2008
  15. Les January 29, 2008
  16. Marti Abernathey January 29, 2008
    • Tobi January 29, 2008
  17. Niss January 29, 2008
  18. Niss January 29, 2008
    • Niss January 29, 2008
  19. Val January 29, 2008
    • Niss January 29, 2008
  20. Autumn Sandeen January 29, 2008
    • Niss January 29, 2008
  21. Marti Abernathey January 29, 2008
  22. Marti Abernathey January 29, 2008
  23. Val January 29, 2008
  24. Val January 29, 2008
  25. Marti Abernathey January 29, 2008
  26. Sue January 29, 2008
  27. Sue January 29, 2008
  28. Marti Abernathey January 29, 2008
  29. Sue January 29, 2008
  30. Marti Abernathey January 29, 2008
  31. Marti Abernathey January 29, 2008
  32. Marti Abernathey January 29, 2008
  33. Sue January 29, 2008
  34. Marti Abernathey January 29, 2008
  35. Marti Abernathey January 29, 2008
  36. Sue January 29, 2008
  37. Sue January 29, 2008
  38. leigh January 29, 2008
  39. leigh January 29, 2008
  40. Stassa January 29, 2008
  41. Stassa January 29, 2008
  42. Marti Abernathey January 29, 2008
  43. Marti Abernathey January 29, 2008
  44. Marti Abernathey January 29, 2008
  45. Val January 29, 2008
  46. Marti Abernathey January 29, 2008
  47. Marti Abernathey January 29, 2008
  48. Marti Abernathey January 29, 2008
  49. Sue January 29, 2008
  50. Sue January 29, 2008
  51. Val January 29, 2008
  52. Val January 29, 2008
  53. Stassa January 29, 2008
  54. Marti Abernathey January 29, 2008
  55. Val January 29, 2008
  56. Marti Abernathey January 29, 2008
    • Val January 31, 2008
  57. Sue January 29, 2008
  58. Val January 29, 2008
    • Stassa January 29, 2008
  59. Sue January 29, 2008
  60. Sue January 29, 2008
  61. Marti Abernathey January 29, 2008
  62. eastsidekate January 29, 2008
  63. eastsidekate January 29, 2008
  64. eastsidekate January 29, 2008
  65. leigh January 29, 2008
  66. leigh January 29, 2008
  67. Val January 29, 2008
  68. Val January 29, 2008
  69. Marti Abernathey January 29, 2008
  70. Val January 29, 2008
  71. leigh January 29, 2008
  72. Sue January 29, 2008
  73. Sue January 29, 2008
  74. Marti Abernathey January 29, 2008
  75. Sue January 29, 2008
  76. Marti Abernathey January 29, 2008
  77. Stassa January 29, 2008
  78. Marti Abernathey January 29, 2008
  79. Marti Abernathey January 29, 2008
  80. Sue January 29, 2008
  81. Marti Abernathey January 29, 2008
  82. Marti Abernathey January 29, 2008
  83. Felix January 29, 2008
  84. Felix January 29, 2008
  85. Marti Abernathey January 29, 2008
  86. Sue January 29, 2008
  87. Sue January 29, 2008
  88. Sue January 29, 2008
  89. Val January 29, 2008
  90. Sue January 29, 2008
  91. Val January 29, 2008
  92. Sue January 29, 2008
  93. Val January 29, 2008
  94. leigh January 29, 2008
  95. Felix January 29, 2008
  96. Val January 29, 2008
  97. Sue January 29, 2008
  98. Val January 29, 2008
  99. Sue January 29, 2008
  100. Sue January 29, 2008
  101. Val January 29, 2008
  102. Sue January 29, 2008
  103. Val January 29, 2008
  104. leigh January 29, 2008
  105. leigh January 29, 2008
  106. Marti Abernathey January 30, 2008
  107. Sue January 30, 2008
  108. Sue January 29, 2008
  109. Marti Abernathey January 30, 2008
    • Sue January 30, 2008
  110. Leigh January 30, 2008
  111. Marti Abernathey January 30, 2008
    • Sue January 30, 2008
  112. Sue January 30, 2008
  113. Sue January 30, 2008
  114. Sue January 30, 2008
  115. Marti Abernathey January 30, 2008
  116. Sue January 29, 2008
  117. Marti Abernathey January 30, 2008
  118. Sue January 30, 2008
  119. Sue January 30, 2008
  120. Stellewriter January 30, 2008
  121. Marti Abernathey January 30, 2008
  122. Sue January 30, 2008
  123. Stellewriter January 30, 2008
  124. Sue January 30, 2008
  125. Marti Abernathey January 30, 2008
  126. Stellewriter January 30, 2008
  127. Sue January 30, 2008
  128. Leigh January 30, 2008
  129. Stellewriter January 30, 2008
  130. Sue January 30, 2008
  131. Marti Abernathey January 30, 2008
  132. Marti Abernathey January 30, 2008
  133. Marti Abernathey January 30, 2008
  134. Marti Abernathey January 30, 2008
  135. eastsidekate January 30, 2008
  136. Marti Abernathey January 30, 2008
  137. Sue January 30, 2008
  138. Marti Abernathey January 30, 2008
  139. Sue January 30, 2008
  140. Danae L. M. January 30, 2008
  141. Danae L. M. January 30, 2008
  142. Felix January 30, 2008
  143. Felix January 29, 2008
  144. Leigh January 30, 2008
    • Just Jennifer February 1, 2008
  145. leigh January 30, 2008
  146. Sue January 30, 2008
  147. Sue January 30, 2008
  148. Marti Abernathey January 30, 2008
  149. Val January 30, 2008
  150. eastsidekate January 30, 2008
    • Sue January 30, 2008
  151. eastsidekate January 30, 2008
  152. Felix January 30, 2008
  153. Sue January 30, 2008
  154. Sue January 30, 2008
  155. Sue January 30, 2008
  156. Ethan St.Pierre January 30, 2008
  157. Sue January 30, 2008
  158. leigh January 30, 2008
  159. leigh January 30, 2008
  160. Sue January 30, 2008
  161. leigh January 30, 2008
  162. leigh January 30, 2008
  163. Sue January 30, 2008
  164. Val January 30, 2008
  165. Val January 30, 2008
  166. Val January 30, 2008
  167. Ethan St.Pierre January 30, 2008
  168. leigh January 30, 2008
  169. leigh January 30, 2008
  170. Tobi January 30, 2008
  171. Just Jennifer January 30, 2008
  172. Just Jennifer January 30, 2008
  173. Marti Abernathey January 30, 2008
  174. Marti Abernathey January 30, 2008
    • Just Jennifer February 1, 2008
  175. Marti Abernathey January 30, 2008
    • Just Jennifer February 1, 2008
  176. Marti Abernathey January 30, 2008
  177. Marti Abernathey January 30, 2008
  178. Marti Abernathey January 30, 2008
  179. Sue January 30, 2008
  180. Just Jennifer January 30, 2008
  181. Sue January 30, 2008
  182. leigh January 30, 2008
  183. Marti Abernathey January 30, 2008
    • leigh January 30, 2008
  184. Sue January 30, 2008
    • Just Jennifer February 1, 2008
  185. Marti Abernathey January 30, 2008
  186. leigh January 30, 2008
  187. Just Jennifer January 30, 2008
  188. Sue January 30, 2008
  189. leigh January 30, 2008
  190. Val January 30, 2008
  191. Just Jennifer January 30, 2008
  192. Just Jennifer January 30, 2008
  193. Just Jennifer January 31, 2008
  194. leigh January 31, 2008
  195. Sue January 31, 2008
  196. Sue January 31, 2008
  197. Just Jennifer January 31, 2008
  198. Val January 30, 2008
  199. Marti Abernathey January 31, 2008
  200. Marti Abernathey January 31, 2008
  201. leigh January 31, 2008
  202. Stassa January 31, 2008
  203. Felix January 31, 2008
  204. Felix January 30, 2008
  205. nexy January 31, 2008
  206. nexy January 30, 2008
  207. Tobi January 31, 2008
  208. Kynn January 31, 2008
  209. Kynn January 31, 2008
  210. Tobi January 31, 2008
  211. Felix January 31, 2008
  212. Felix January 31, 2008
  213. Just Jennifer January 31, 2008
  214. Ethan St.Pierre January 31, 2008
  215. Tobi January 31, 2008
  216. Laura_Mac January 31, 2008
  217. Just Jennifer January 31, 2008
  218. Just Jennifer January 31, 2008
  219. Tobi January 31, 2008
  220. Tobi January 31, 2008
  221. Marti Abernathey February 1, 2008
  222. Felix February 1, 2008
    • Sue January 30, 2008
  223. leigh February 1, 2008
  224. leigh February 1, 2008
  225. Just Jennifer February 1, 2008
  226. Just Jennifer February 1, 2008
  227. Marti Abernathey February 1, 2008
  228. Marti Abernathey February 1, 2008
  229. Marti Abernathey February 1, 2008
    • Just Jennifer January 30, 2008
  230. Marti Abernathey February 1, 2008
  231. Felix February 1, 2008
    • Stassa January 29, 2008
  232. Felix February 1, 2008
    • leigh January 30, 2008
  233. leigh February 1, 2008
  234. leigh February 1, 2008
  235. Marti Abernathey February 1, 2008
  236. Just Jennifer February 1, 2008
  237. Just Jennifer February 1, 2008
  238. Sue February 1, 2008
  239. Just Jennifer February 1, 2008
    • Sue February 1, 2008
  240. Marti Abernathey February 1, 2008
  241. Marti Abernathey February 1, 2008
  242. Sue February 1, 2008
  243. Marti Abernathey February 1, 2008
    • Marti Abernathey February 1, 2008
  244. Marti Abernathey February 1, 2008
  245. Sue February 1, 2008
  246. Just Jennifer February 1, 2008
  247. Just Jennifer February 1, 2008
  248. Sue February 1, 2008
  249. Sue February 1, 2008
  250. Sue February 1, 2008
  251. Sue February 1, 2008
  252. Marti Abernathey February 1, 2008
  253. Marti Abernathey February 1, 2008
  254. Marti Abernathey February 1, 2008
  255. Marti Abernathey February 1, 2008
  256. Just Jennifer February 1, 2008
  257. Marti Abernathey February 1, 2008
  258. Marti Abernathey February 1, 2008
    • Just Jennifer February 1, 2008
  259. Marti Abernathey February 1, 2008
    • Just Jennifer February 1, 2008
  260. Harry Benjamin February 1, 2008
  261. Harry Benjamin February 1, 2008
img_5800e5bd88d8a
Johns Hopkins Resumes Trans Care
DL-art
The New York Magazine lies to parents about trans children
92
The media is lying about why NC is being sued
91
What the US Attorney General actually said about trans people & fighting NC in court
transphobia5
The Politics of Transphobia
img_579a295a28d15
Is Sadism Popular With TERFs? A Chat With An Ex-Gendercrit
chai
EEOC Commissioner: “Contrary state or local laws provide no defense to an employer that violates Title VII”
85
Study: Trans kid’s gender implicit; govt report condemns conversion therapy
95c
The Gill Foundation & NCTE choose money over trans lives
KrellTitle
In Memory of Terri Williams Moore (1941–1976)
87
[Updated] Predatory publishers and their dupes
84
The NY Times goes concern trolling
95c
The Gill Foundation & NCTE choose money over trans lives
transphobia5
The Politics of Transphobia
86
Fight back: Report Mississippi & North Carolina HATE here!
CitizensForResponsiblePolicy_CreepyGuy
The 2008 Gainesville Bathroom Bill TV Spot Revisited