Full SFGN Interview: ‘I am not a bigot’ Says Gender Identity Watch’s Cathy Brennan

Download PDF

Recently the South Florida Gay News interviewed me for an article on the TERFs, Cathy Brennan and her group, Gender Identity Watch:

The Web is where this feud appears to have escalated with Brennan trading barbs between journalists and advocates from the transgender community who claim Brennan and her blog are insensitive.

“I believe the petition served to clearly demonstrate that many thousands of feminists view the GIW team to be a hate group,” said Cristan Williams, editor of Transadvocate.com. “I think that it also offered a chance for Brennan’s victims to connect with many others and understand that they were not alone.”

Brennan discounted Williams’ accusations as “nuts” and said “Cristan has an axe to grind and let her grind it.”

Meanwhile at the Southern Poverty Law Center, where the Intelligence Project has been heralded by the National Review as “one of the most respected anti-terror organizations in the world,” Beirich acknowledged there have been some issues with Gender Identity Watch, but refused to deem it a hate group.

“It’s not that we don’t consider some of the things that have happened there to be really ugly,” Beirich said. “It doesn’t qualify as a hate group under our definition because a hate group has to have some membership, like a group.”

Some have claimed that the article failed to adequately describe the issues. The piece is short an only briefly quotes the interview questions I answered. Missing from the SFGN piece is any historical context. For the sake of clarity, here are my complete answers to the SDGN’s interview questions:

South Florida Gay News: What is your prior experience with Cathy Brennan and Gender Identity Watch?

Cristan Williams: The historical TERF movement was directly involved in stripping access to psychological and medical care from the trans community in the 1980s. The term TERF (Trans Exclusionary Radical Feminists) was popularized in 2008 by the non-transgender feminist community because these women felt as if their discourse was being colonized by an extremist faction. Feminist women began using this term as a way to distinguish the TERF rhetoric from larger feminist discourse.

I encountered Brennan as being an opinion leader in the modern iteration of the TERF movement. I became aware of Brennan a few years ago as the power behind an effort to have trans people stripped of UN protections. The ideology promoted by Brennan’s group is featured in TERF conferences, meetings, lectures and direct actions across the globe.

GIW calls itself a team, not a group. The GIW team promotes a world view in which trans people and protections are not only watched, but correlated with the suffering of cisgender women. Racist groups employ similar tactics by tracking improvements in racial equality while correlating gains in equality with perceived wrongs committed by groups they exist to oppress.

For instance, here are a few posts from today’s GIW social media stream:

image (1)

In Brennan’s reality, this isn’t bigotry

image

Promoting propaganda from an ex-gay group

Note that GIW features the talking points of a known ex-gay group and proudly attacks known trans activists.

Brennan’s group asserts that the term TERF is a pejorative and rejects the idea that people are born with a subjective awareness of the body’s physical sex. Brennan’s brand of “feminism” promotes the notion that women can and probably should choose to become lesbians (the so-called political lesbian) and that people – like myself – who disagree with her are men’s rights activists (MRAs).

SFGN: What are your thoughts about the petition to ask SPLC to declare GIW a Hate group?

CW: The petition was created by a feminist group called, Secular Women. I believe the petition served to clearly demonstrate that many 1000s of feminists view the GIW team to be a hate group. I think that it also offered a chance for Brennan’s victims to connect with many others and understand that they were not alone.

SFGN: What is your role with The TransAdvocate.com?

CW: I am the editor.

 

 

[column size=”one-half”]

Tip this TransAdvocate!

Writers for the TransAdvocate work hard to bring you news and commentary. If you found this article meaningful, let the author know that you appreciate the work they do with a tip!
[/column] [column size=”one-half” last=”true”] TipJar


[/column]

180 Comments

  1. DarlieB February 12, 2014
    • Justin Allen Norwood February 12, 2014
      • Sinopaa February 13, 2014
        • Justin Allen Norwood February 13, 2014
          • Cristan February 13, 2014
          • Justin Allen Norwood February 13, 2014
          • marti386 February 13, 2014
          • Justin Allen Norwood February 13, 2014
          • marti386 February 13, 2014
          • Justin Allen Norwood February 13, 2014
          • marti386 February 13, 2014
          • Justin Allen Norwood February 13, 2014
          • Cristan February 13, 2014
          • Justin Allen Norwood February 13, 2014
          • marti386 February 13, 2014
          • danah sparkle February 16, 2014
          • Kathy11 February 13, 2014
          • Justin Allen Norwood February 13, 2014
          • marti386 February 13, 2014
          • Friesjones February 13, 2014
          • danah sparkle February 16, 2014
          • Justin Allen Norwood February 16, 2014
          • danah sparkle February 16, 2014
          • Justin Allen Norwood February 16, 2014
          • danah sparkle February 16, 2014
          • Justin Allen Norwood February 16, 2014
          • Justin Allen Norwood February 16, 2014
          • danah sparkle February 16, 2014
          • Justin Allen Norwood February 16, 2014
          • marti386 February 17, 2014
          • Kathy11 February 17, 2014
          • marti386 February 17, 2014
          • marti386 February 16, 2014
          • Justin Allen Norwood February 16, 2014
          • marti386 February 17, 2014
          • Kathy11 February 17, 2014
          • marti386 February 17, 2014
          • Kathy11 February 17, 2014
          • Guest February 17, 2014
          • Kathy11 February 18, 2014
          • marti386 February 18, 2014
          • Kathy11 February 17, 2014
          • Kathy11 February 17, 2014
          • Kathy11 February 17, 2014
          • Kathy11 February 17, 2014
          • Kathy11 February 18, 2014
          • Kathy11 February 17, 2014
          • marti386 February 17, 2014
          • Kathy11 February 17, 2014
          • christian_transgender February 17, 2014
          • christian_transgender February 17, 2014
          • marti386 February 18, 2014
          • christian_transgender February 18, 2014
          • marti386 February 18, 2014
          • christian_transgender February 18, 2014
          • christian_transgender February 17, 2014
          • Justin Allen Norwood February 13, 2014
          • marti386 February 13, 2014
          • Cristan February 13, 2014
          • Justin Allen Norwood February 13, 2014
          • Bonze Anne Rose Blayk February 14, 2014
          • Friesjones February 13, 2014
          • christian_transgender February 16, 2014
          • Justin Allen Norwood February 16, 2014
          • marti386 February 13, 2014
          • Justin Allen Norwood February 13, 2014
          • marti386 February 13, 2014
          • Justin Allen Norwood February 13, 2014
          • marti386 February 13, 2014
          • Justin Allen Norwood February 13, 2014
          • marti386 February 13, 2014
          • Justin Allen Norwood February 13, 2014
          • Kathy11 February 13, 2014
          • Max Vincent February 18, 2014
          • Justin Allen Norwood February 21, 2014
          • MarekT February 22, 2014
          • Kathy11 February 13, 2014
          • Justin Allen Norwood February 13, 2014
          • Kathy11 February 14, 2014
          • Max Vincent February 18, 2014
          • Cristan February 13, 2014
          • christian_transgender February 16, 2014
          • Max Vincent February 18, 2014
          • Kathy11 February 13, 2014
          • christian_transgender February 17, 2014
      • Lisa Harney February 13, 2014
        • Justin Allen Norwood February 13, 2014
          • Cristan February 13, 2014
          • Justin Allen Norwood February 13, 2014
          • Cristan February 13, 2014
          • Justin Allen Norwood February 13, 2014
          • Cristan February 13, 2014
          • Justin Allen Norwood February 13, 2014
          • Cristan February 13, 2014
          • Justin Allen Norwood February 13, 2014
          • Cristan February 13, 2014
          • Justin Allen Norwood February 13, 2014
          • Cristan February 13, 2014
          • christian_transgender February 18, 2014
          • Kathy11 February 13, 2014
          • Max Vincent February 18, 2014
          • Justin Allen Norwood February 21, 2014
          • christian_transgender February 17, 2014
          • christian_transgender February 17, 2014
          • danah sparkle February 17, 2014
          • Wangchuck February 17, 2014
          • danah sparkle February 17, 2014
          • christian_transgender February 17, 2014
          • Wangchuck February 17, 2014
          • marti386 February 18, 2014
          • danah sparkle February 18, 2014
          • Lisa Harney February 14, 2014
          • Justin Allen Norwood February 15, 2014
          • MarekT February 15, 2014
          • Justin Allen Norwood February 15, 2014
          • MarekT February 15, 2014
          • Justin Allen Norwood February 15, 2014
          • MarekT February 15, 2014
          • christian_transgender February 17, 2014
          • marti386 February 15, 2014
          • marti386 February 15, 2014
          • danah sparkle February 17, 2014
          • danah sparkle February 16, 2014
        • Friesjones February 13, 2014
      • translegalhistorian February 13, 2014
      • christian_transgender February 16, 2014
  2. Max Vincent February 12, 2014
    • translegalhistorian February 13, 2014
      • Max Vincent February 16, 2014
        • christian_transgender February 16, 2014
  3. christian_transgender February 13, 2014
  4. Wangchuck February 15, 2014
    • Kathy11 February 15, 2014
      • Wangchuck February 16, 2014
        • MarekT February 16, 2014
          • christian_transgender February 17, 2014
          • danah sparkle February 17, 2014
          • christian_transgender February 17, 2014
          • danah sparkle February 17, 2014
          • christian_transgender February 17, 2014
          • danah sparkle February 17, 2014
          • christian_transgender February 17, 2014
          • danah sparkle February 17, 2014
          • christian_transgender February 17, 2014
          • danah sparkle February 17, 2014
          • christian_transgender February 17, 2014
          • Wangchuck February 17, 2014
          • christian_transgender February 17, 2014
          • Wangchuck February 17, 2014
          • danah sparkle February 17, 2014
          • Kathy11 February 17, 2014
          • christian_transgender February 17, 2014
          • danah sparkle February 17, 2014
          • christian_transgender February 17, 2014
          • danah sparkle February 17, 2014
          • danah sparkle February 17, 2014
        • Kathy11 February 17, 2014
          • christian_transgender February 17, 2014
    • christian_transgender February 16, 2014
      • Wangchuck February 17, 2014
        • christian_transgender February 17, 2014
        • danah sparkle February 17, 2014
          • christian_transgender February 17, 2014
        • Kathy11 February 17, 2014
        • Kathy11 February 17, 2014
  5. christian_transgender February 16, 2014
    • christian_transgender February 17, 2014
  6. danah sparkle February 17, 2014
    • Wangchuck February 17, 2014
      • danah sparkle February 17, 2014
        • christian_transgender February 17, 2014
      • danah sparkle February 17, 2014
        • Kathy11 February 17, 2014
      • Kathy11 February 17, 2014
        • christian_transgender February 17, 2014
    • christian_transgender February 17, 2014
  7. Sami Hawkins February 17, 2014
    • danah sparkle February 17, 2014
    • christian_transgender February 17, 2014
  8. christian_transgender February 17, 2014

Add Comment

DL-art
The New York Magazine lies to parents about trans children

Jesse Singal, Senior Editor at nymag.com, has enlisted his New York...

target1-924x462[1]
BREAKING: due to Target’s trans policy, voyeur accessed women’s changing room?

A case of voyeurism that has gripped the media was initially reported on...

92
The media is lying about why NC is being sued

By Cristan Williams @cristanwilliams Almost without exception, all news stories covering...

91
What the US Attorney General actually said about trans people & fighting NC in court

On Monday, May 9th, the United States Attorney General, Loretta Lynch...

transphobia5
The Politics of Transphobia

Bathroom Bills & The Dialectic of Oppression From the KKK to...

img_579a295a28d15
Is Sadism Popular With TERFs? A Chat With An Ex-Gendercrit

BY Rani Baker @destroyed4com4t Let’s get this out of the way: deep...

chai
EEOC Commissioner: “Contrary state or local laws provide no defense to an employer that violates Title VII”

Recently in BuzzFeed in the article Feds “Ready” For Transgender Discrimination...

85
Study: Trans kid’s gender implicit; govt report condemns conversion therapy

A recent study found that the gender identity of trans children...

KrellTitle
In Memory of Terri Williams Moore (1941–1976)

A trans historian considers the backwards progress of the way media...

87
[Updated] Predatory publishers and their dupes

While it’s well and good to call out those who denigrate trans...

84
The NY Times goes concern trolling

On August 22, 2015 the NY Times ran an article by Richard...

calledterf
So, someone called you a TERF. Now what?

There are many things possible in the universe. If you are...