Back to Oz

frankoz.jpg



I really do hesitate to even write this post, as the topic is a rehash of one of the ugliest times for GLBT unity I’ve ever seen. Recently Matt Foreman said the following on the Michelangelo Signorile Show concerning the ENDA debacle:

I think what really happened is the Speaker’s people said ‘look, Congress has a terrible reputation right now, they’re not delivering for any progressive causes, what do we do to deliver for our progressive allies?’ That means labor, health, and environment, and gays. And so, I mean… I don’t know this for a fact, but I’d bet my life this is what happened. They went to Barney frank, they said, ‘what do we need to do to pass ENDA?’ Representative Frank, who’s always been pretty squeamish on the trans issue, … and I guess I can say these things because I’m leaving my job, ya know, said ‘look the best way to pass ENDA and the easiest way is to take out gender identity.’ And I don’t think the Speaker’s people thought this through, didn’t think it through and said ‘lets do it. ‘

Yesterday, Barney Frank came on Signorile’s show to respond to Foreman’s statement and said:

He just made that up, that’s not remotely how it happened. He also has no basis for talking about my attitude on transgender people because I’ve had one set of conversations with Matt Foreman about transgender people. In 2002, when he was the head of Empire State Pride Agenda, he lobbied hard to get through the New York legislature a bill that did exactly what our bill did last year, it covered discrimination based on sexual orientation, but excluded people that were transgender. Some people didn’t like that. Tom Duane said at the time that Matt Foreman excluded him from meetings on the subject. Matt Foreman not only helped get that bill through, frankly, and this I disagreed with, as part of the deal to get it though, that year the Empire State Pride Agenda endorsed the Republican George Pataki for reelection over an outstanding African American Democrat, Carl McCall. So you had Matt Foreman guiding to passage an ENDA bill that didn’t cover transgender, it was called SONDA for the State of New York, and in return, denying an endorsement that I think he should have gotten on [unintelligible] to Carl McCall. The reason I talked about it with him was because called me around that time, this is late 2002, and said ‘I’m being criticized for doing this, would you come to a meeting that we’re having in New York to celebrate it and give an award for Gov Pataki to show that uh people shouldn’t be attacking me for it.’ And even though I did disagree with decision to make make the deal with Pataki, I do believe that you work together with each other, and you try to be supportive, and I went up there.

Since Foreman has said in the past that he regrets that choice and thinks it was a mistake, I’m not sure why Congressman Frank is bringing this up, except to smear him. Amazingly, Frank is admitting that he helped Foreman in his attempt to exclude gender identity from SONDA. Yet when asked about Foreman’s statement about his squeamishness, he said:

“I don’t usually talk like this, but no one in the history of the United States Congress has advocated explicitly for including transgender poeople in legislation as much as I have. In 1999 when we were doing hate crimes, I brought up the transgender issue, and said that it was very important to include people with transgender, both in committee and on the floor. I testified this past fall about the importance of including people with transgender. Here’s what troubles me. When they say I’m squeamish, what they’re pointing out, is what I’ve said from the beginning, to various advocates including people within the transgender community, we have a political problem here. We’ve have been working the issues of gays and lesbians longer than transgender. Some of the intial reaction you get when you first bring up an issue is problematic. And so transgender people are victims of the same kind of virulent prejudice that we who are gay and lesbian were, 35 years ago, and we haven’t had as much progress in dealing with it. This is a case of complain about the messenger. I told them that we had this problem, and they didn’t listen.”

I’m not sure how you can claim the title of great advocate for transgender people, when you’ve helped to exclude them in two different pieces of legislation.

During the interview Signorile pointed out to Frank that Foreman had said that he was squeamish about transgender people. Signorile then told Frank about his own history of squeamishness about transgender people. Still Frank insisted that he’s never been “squeamish” about transgender people.

I don’t know why you’d impute that to me. I have never had that view. There was a time when people weren’t paying much attention to people with transgender. But I’ve always believed when you ban discrimination, you ban it against everybody.

But the experiences of transgender women through the years, paint a very different picture of Congressman Frank. In 2001 , Karen Ann Taylor asked Frank why transgender people weren’t being included in ENDA. Of that experience she said:

As I approached him I cordially introduced myself, shook his hand, and cut right to the chase. I wanted to know why the transgendered were not represented in ENDA. The answer was such a surprise, I was dumbfounded at first. The whole crux of purposely and intentionally disallowing the transgendered from ENDA was something of the effect ‘it would cause it not to pass… it would fail due to penises and vaginas showering together in the workplace.’

Huh? You gotta be kidding! This was the most asinine thing I’d heard! When I asked what about gay and straight men in the same shower, the reply was essentially ‘that’s not a problem, not even in the military. Even the bathroom is not the issue. But penises and vaginas in the same shower will cause it to fail. But we can take care of that with an amendment.’

But that’s the VERY argument that was used by the creator of Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell. From Wikipedia:

In 2000, Northwestern University Professor Charles Moskos, the principal author of DADT (which, as originally coined by Moskos, was “Don’t Ask Don’t Tell; Don’t Seek Don’t Flaunt”), told ‘Lingua Franca’ that he felt that policy will be gone within five to ten years. Moskos also dismissed the unit cohesion argument, instead arguing that gay people should be banned due to ‘modesty rights’, saying ‘Fuck unit cohesion. I don’t care about that…I should not be forced to shower with a woman. I should not be forced to shower with a gay [man].’

Another incident was described by Miranda Stevens-Miller:

A little while later, I found Barney without a group of people around him, so I once again engaged him in conversation. ‘So,’ I said, ‘does your support of transgender inclusion in the VAWA mean that you might be changing your mind about inclusion of gender-variant people in ENDA?’ An innocent enough question, but you would have thought that I was threatening him with a loaded weapon. He got red in the face and started shouting, ‘Never.’ His problem was that until we could answer the question of ‘people with penises in [women’s] showers,’ there is no way that he would support it. The conversation got rather heated to say the least. And with Barney speaking very loudly and repeatedly about ‘penises in showers,’ we attracted a lot of attention in the restaurant.

But the reality of penises being in showers with vagina’s is small. First of all, how many employers have communal showers? Of those, how many of those have open shower areas? I’ve spoken to quite a few of my natal women friends that tell me that many shower areas in women’s locker rooms have shower stalls in them. That they aren’t “communal” in the same sort of way mens’ showers are. So what are the odds that an employer has to have showers, then has to have communal shower areas, then add to that, what employer can’t make accommodations for their transgender workers (showering before or after everyone else, showering in another location). All in all, you’re talking about a hand full of jobs. Out of those handful of jobs, how many would have a transgender woman that is preoperative that would want to flash their genitals around in a communal shower in the workplace? I think the odds of Jesus coming back and fishing with Marilyn Manson on the Potomac is more likely. But that seems to be the standard reasoning Frank has given since 2000, as to why we shouldn’t be included.

Then Frank blamed transgender people and their advocates for the lack lobbying.

Part of the problem, frankly, is with the transgender community and some of those who put that in the forefront, because they didn’t lobby. The only time they started lobbying is when we said ‘You know what, we don’t have the votes for this, we gotta to do it partially.’ Then they began lobbying the Democrats that were supportive. I’ve never seen a worse job of lobbying. For years, literally years, I have been begging them to start talking to people about this, and have said you, look, have political problems here, I wish we didn’t but we do, and you have to deal with them.

In reality, GenderPAC started lobbying Congress in 1995, the National Transgender Advocacy Coalition in 1999, and the National Center for Transgender Equality in 2005. Until recently, those lobbying efforts were done as by unpaid citizens, and were done without the help of gay and lesbian organizations. Transgender activists have been asking for help with access for years, but had been largely ignored.

I find it puzzling as well that such a stanch advocate of transgender people like Frank who aren’t “squeamish”, would continue to use disease phraseology when referring to transgender people (as “people with transgender”). If he’s trying to advocate for us, a simple first step would be to stop saying that.

While the rhetoric Congressman Frank is spinning is nothing new (see also: October-November 2007), the timing now seems odd. As I mentioned in a previous post, both Democratic candidates for president have publicly stated their support for an ENDA that includes gender identity (with Clinton going even further and stating support for gender expression as well). The Democratic tsunami on the horizon bodes well for a GI inclusive ENDA. Everything is trending towards inclusion of transgender inclusion in the 2009 ENDA. Why isn’t Frank?

269 Comments

  1. Val February 15, 2008
  2. Val February 15, 2008
  3. Sandy February 16, 2008
  4. Sandy February 15, 2008
  5. Marti Abernathey February 16, 2008
  6. Marti Abernathey February 15, 2008
  7. Polar Bear February 16, 2008
  8. Polar Bear February 16, 2008
  9. Felix February 16, 2008
  10. Felix February 16, 2008
  11. Sandy February 16, 2008
  12. Sandy February 16, 2008
  13. Felix February 17, 2008
  14. Felix February 17, 2008
  15. Felix February 17, 2008
  16. Kat February 17, 2008
  17. Kat February 17, 2008
  18. Sandy February 17, 2008
  19. Sandy February 17, 2008
  20. Laura_Mac February 17, 2008
  21. Laura_Mac February 17, 2008
  22. Laura_Mac February 17, 2008
  23. Felix February 17, 2008
  24. Felix February 17, 2008
  25. Felix February 17, 2008
  26. Felix February 17, 2008
  27. Polar Bear February 18, 2008
  28. Polar Bear February 18, 2008
  29. Polar Bear February 17, 2008
  30. Sandy February 21, 2008
  31. Sandy February 20, 2008
  32. Laura_Mac February 21, 2008
  33. Laura_Mac February 20, 2008
  34. Sandy February 21, 2008
  35. Sandy February 21, 2008
  36. Sandy February 20, 2008
  37. Sandy February 21, 2008
  38. Sandy February 20, 2008
  39. Laura_Mac February 21, 2008
  40. Laura_Mac February 20, 2008
  41. Sandy February 22, 2008
  42. Sandy February 21, 2008
  43. Val February 22, 2008
  44. Val February 22, 2008
  45. Felix February 22, 2008
  46. Felix February 22, 2008
  47. Polar Bear February 22, 2008
  48. Polar Bear February 22, 2008
  49. Sandy February 23, 2008
  50. Sandy February 22, 2008
  51. Sandy February 23, 2008
  52. Sandy February 22, 2008
  53. Felix February 23, 2008
  54. Felix February 23, 2008
  55. Val February 23, 2008
  56. Val February 23, 2008
  57. Sandy February 24, 2008
  58. Sandy February 24, 2008
  59. Niss February 24, 2008
  60. Niss February 24, 2008
  61. Niss February 24, 2008
  62. Niss February 24, 2008
  63. Felix February 24, 2008
  64. Felix February 24, 2008
  65. Sandy February 24, 2008
  66. Sandy February 24, 2008
  67. Sandy February 24, 2008
  68. Battybattybats February 24, 2008
  69. Battybattybats February 24, 2008
  70. Felix February 24, 2008
  71. Felix February 24, 2008
  72. Val February 24, 2008
  73. Val February 24, 2008
  74. Val February 24, 2008
  75. Val February 24, 2008
  76. Polar Bear February 25, 2008
  77. Polar Bear February 24, 2008
  78. Sandy February 25, 2008
  79. Sandy February 24, 2008
  80. Sandy February 25, 2008
  81. Sandy February 24, 2008
  82. Sandy February 25, 2008
  83. Sandy February 24, 2008
  84. Felix February 25, 2008
  85. Felix February 25, 2008
  86. Val February 25, 2008
  87. Val February 25, 2008
  88. Battybattybats February 25, 2008
  89. Battybattybats February 25, 2008
  90. Susan February 26, 2008
  91. Susan February 25, 2008
  92. Marti Abernathey February 26, 2008
  93. Marti Abernathey February 25, 2008
  94. Val February 26, 2008
  95. Val February 25, 2008
  96. Val February 26, 2008
  97. Val February 25, 2008
  98. Sandy February 26, 2008
  99. Sandy February 25, 2008
  100. Niss February 26, 2008
  101. Niss February 25, 2008
  102. Sandy February 26, 2008
  103. Sandy February 25, 2008
  104. Susan February 26, 2008
  105. Susan February 25, 2008
  106. Sandy February 26, 2008
  107. Sandy February 25, 2008
  108. Niss February 26, 2008
  109. Niss February 25, 2008
  110. Niss February 26, 2008
  111. Niss February 25, 2008
  112. Niss February 26, 2008
  113. Niss February 25, 2008
  114. Felix February 26, 2008
  115. Felix February 26, 2008
  116. Val February 26, 2008
  117. Val February 26, 2008
  118. Val February 26, 2008
  119. Val February 26, 2008
  120. Val February 26, 2008
  121. Val February 26, 2008
  122. Battybattybats February 26, 2008
  123. Battybattybats February 26, 2008
  124. Val February 26, 2008
  125. Val February 26, 2008
  126. Battybattybats February 26, 2008
  127. Battybattybats February 26, 2008
  128. Val February 26, 2008
  129. Val February 26, 2008
  130. Mercedes Allen February 26, 2008
  131. Mercedes Allen February 26, 2008
  132. Marti Abernathey February 26, 2008
  133. Marti Abernathey February 26, 2008
  134. Sandy February 26, 2008
  135. Sandy February 26, 2008
  136. Sandy February 26, 2008
  137. Sandy February 26, 2008
  138. Val February 26, 2008
  139. Val February 26, 2008
  140. Battybattybats February 26, 2008
  141. Battybattybats February 26, 2008
  142. Battybattybats February 26, 2008
  143. Battybattybats February 26, 2008
  144. Felix February 26, 2008
  145. Felix February 26, 2008
  146. Sandy February 26, 2008
  147. Sandy February 26, 2008
  148. Sandy February 26, 2008
  149. Sandy February 26, 2008
  150. Niss February 26, 2008
  151. Niss February 26, 2008
  152. Niss February 26, 2008
  153. Niss February 26, 2008
  154. Val February 26, 2008
  155. Val February 26, 2008
  156. Val February 26, 2008
  157. Val February 26, 2008
  158. Val February 26, 2008
  159. Val February 26, 2008
  160. Susan February 27, 2008
  161. Susan February 26, 2008
  162. Val February 27, 2008
  163. Val February 26, 2008
  164. Battybattybats February 27, 2008
  165. Battybattybats February 26, 2008
  166. Felix February 27, 2008
  167. Felix February 26, 2008
  168. Sandy February 27, 2008
  169. Sandy February 27, 2008
  170. Sandy February 27, 2008
  171. Sandy February 27, 2008
  172. Val February 27, 2008
  173. Val February 27, 2008
  174. Schala February 27, 2008
  175. Schala February 27, 2008
  176. Val February 27, 2008
  177. Val February 27, 2008
  178. Battybattybats February 27, 2008
  179. Battybattybats February 27, 2008
  180. Val February 27, 2008
  181. Val February 27, 2008
  182. Val February 27, 2008
  183. Val February 27, 2008
  184. Felix February 27, 2008
  185. Felix February 27, 2008
  186. Danae of the Sun February 27, 2008
  187. Danae of the Sun February 27, 2008
  188. Battybattybats February 28, 2008
  189. Battybattybats February 28, 2008
  190. Sandy February 29, 2008
  191. Sandy February 28, 2008
  192. Sandy February 29, 2008
  193. Sandy February 28, 2008
  194. Sandy February 29, 2008
  195. Sandy February 28, 2008
  196. Battybattybats February 29, 2008
  197. Battybattybats February 28, 2008
  198. Sandy February 28, 2008
  199. Sandy February 29, 2008
  200. Battybattybats February 29, 2008
  201. Battybattybats February 29, 2008
  202. Battybattybats February 29, 2008
  203. Battybattybats February 29, 2008
  204. Niss February 29, 2008
  205. Niss February 29, 2008
  206. Marti Abernathey February 29, 2008
  207. Marti Abernathey February 29, 2008
  208. Niss February 29, 2008
  209. Niss February 29, 2008
  210. Battybattybats February 29, 2008
  211. Battybattybats February 29, 2008
  212. Val February 29, 2008
  213. Val February 29, 2008
  214. Sandy February 29, 2008
  215. Sandy February 29, 2008
  216. Battybattybats February 29, 2008
  217. Battybattybats February 29, 2008
  218. Sandy February 29, 2008
  219. Sandy February 29, 2008
  220. Battybattybats February 29, 2008
  221. Battybattybats February 29, 2008
  222. Sandy February 29, 2008
  223. Sandy February 29, 2008
  224. Battybattybats February 29, 2008
  225. Battybattybats February 29, 2008
  226. Battybattybats February 29, 2008
  227. Battybattybats February 29, 2008
  228. Sandy February 29, 2008
  229. Sandy February 29, 2008
  230. Marti Abernathey February 29, 2008
  231. Marti Abernathey February 29, 2008
  232. Battybattybats February 29, 2008
  233. Battybattybats February 29, 2008
  234. Niss February 29, 2008
  235. Niss February 29, 2008
  236. Danae of the Sun February 29, 2008
  237. Danae of the Sun February 29, 2008
  238. Battybattybats March 1, 2008
  239. Battybattybats February 29, 2008
  240. Felix February 29, 2008
  241. Felix March 1, 2008
  242. Sandy March 1, 2008
  243. Sandy February 29, 2008
  244. Niss March 1, 2008
  245. Niss March 1, 2008
  246. Battybattybats March 1, 2008
  247. Battybattybats March 1, 2008
  248. Polar Bear March 2, 2008
  249. Polar Bear March 1, 2008
  250. Polar Bear March 2, 2008
  251. Polar Bear March 1, 2008
  252. Danae of the Sun March 2, 2008
  253. Danae of the Sun March 2, 2008
  254. Danae of the Sun March 2, 2008
  255. Danae of the Sun March 2, 2008
  256. Sandy March 5, 2008
  257. Sandy March 4, 2008
  258. Battybattybats March 5, 2008
  259. Battybattybats March 5, 2008
  260. Polar Bear March 5, 2008
  261. Polar Bear March 5, 2008
  262. Niss March 6, 2008
  263. Niss March 5, 2008
  264. Felix March 6, 2008
  265. Felix March 5, 2008
  266. Battybattybats March 6, 2008
  267. Battybattybats March 5, 2008
  268. marla March 28, 2008
  269. marla March 28, 2008
img_5800e5bd88d8a
Johns Hopkins Resumes Trans Care
DL-art
The New York Magazine lies to parents about trans children
92
The media is lying about why NC is being sued
91
What the US Attorney General actually said about trans people & fighting NC in court
transphobia5
The Politics of Transphobia
img_579a295a28d15
Is Sadism Popular With TERFs? A Chat With An Ex-Gendercrit
chai
EEOC Commissioner: “Contrary state or local laws provide no defense to an employer that violates Title VII”
85
Study: Trans kid’s gender implicit; govt report condemns conversion therapy
95c
The Gill Foundation & NCTE choose money over trans lives
KrellTitle
In Memory of Terri Williams Moore (1941–1976)
87
[Updated] Predatory publishers and their dupes
84
The NY Times goes concern trolling
95c
The Gill Foundation & NCTE choose money over trans lives
transphobia5
The Politics of Transphobia
86
Fight back: Report Mississippi & North Carolina HATE here!
CitizensForResponsiblePolicy_CreepyGuy
The 2008 Gainesville Bathroom Bill TV Spot Revisited