Am I A Woman Born Transsexual?: The Politics of Trans-Identities

The intersection of internet wars sometimes brings interesting observations to mind, and today one such intersection really spoke to me. Recently Jasper over at Jasper’s wardrobe has made some pretty controversial things about gender and transwomen. From “just your average straight white guy with a cunt“:

“I do not recognize any claims to the truth of a gender. All genders are constructed. From this standpoint I see hormones and SRS as body modifications. That is great. Tattoos piercings and hormones. You have control over your own body. But I consider someone who explores a gender outside the binary to have an equally ‘true’ gender as someone who uses medical technology to take on a ‘classical’ gender.

He is correct that gender is a social construct. Simply by looking at the accepted definition of gender, we know that.

genderthe behavioral, cultural, or psychological traits typically associated with one sex.

They are traits that are typically associated (by society), or implied by visual or auditory gender cues. When we see a baby and they are wearing pink, in this culture that is a cue that the baby is a girl. What Jasper is talking about above is gender identity, not gender itself.

gender identity – The degree to which a person identifies as male, female, or some combination. It is the internal framework, constructed over time, which enables an individual to organise a self-concept and to perform socially in regards to their perceived sex and gender.”

Gender identity is an internal framework, but gender itself is an external one. As a friend of mine says, “gender should not be used as shorthand.”  Simply because you claim a the gender identity of a woman, doesn’t mean you are gendered as one. I identified as a woman before I actually was perceived by the world as one. If the world sees your gender/sexual orientation as male/heterosexual, your experience and privilege will be based on that.

transgender – of, relating to, or being a person (as a transsexual or transvestite) who identifies with or expresses a gender identity that differs from the one which corresponds to the person’s sex at birth.transsexual – a person who strongly identifies with the opposite sex and may seek to live as a member of this sex especially by undergoing surgery and hormone therapy to obtain the necessary physical appearance (as by changing the external sex organs)

In the same way that gender and gender identity aren’t synonymous, neither are transsexual and transgender.  Transgender is an umbrella term, of which transsexuals fall under. But also under the umbrella are: cross-dresser, transvestite, androgynes, genderqueer, and drag kings & queens. Jasper claims to be a transgender woman. While I agree that Jasper may be “transgender” because of who he “identifies with”, saying he is a woman isn’t factually correct. Gendering is done through presentation. In his videos he neither appears to be transitioning away from a male gender or moving towards a female gender. This isn’t a smear, it’s an observation based on the meaning of the words.

Veronica over at Women In Love writes:

“My plea to the trans community has always been for coming together and to have understanding and solidarity as a goal for all LGBTQI2-S people. I hope that both camps in the trans community and all subgroups in the LGBTQI2-S fold, will eventually find a place to meet in respect for one another. This is the example we should be setting for the greater community and for future generations.

It reminds me of this line from The Pretenders ‘Waste Not, Want Not’ – ‘The life you take is your political voice.’ I’m proud of who I am as a person, and I live with the choices I have made. If someone insults me, I just walk away. I don’t want to engage in destructive trans-identity political arguments.”

While I agree with Veronica that unity is needed, I think the discussion about what a “transgender woman” is, is important. People of color are offended when white people speak in their name. Women are offended when men speak for them. When someone that is appropriating my identity or speaking in my name, I’m offended.

cissexism – The belief that transsexual genders are less legitimate than, and mere imitations of, cissexual genders.

Speaking with authority on cissexism of trans-women while still living in a male gender, is offensive to me. It belittles the memory of all those that have died because of their gender presentation and the lives of those who are going through gender transition. While I accept Jasper’s gender identity, I will not stand quietly while someone belittles those who pay a hefty price for being who they are.

114 Comments

  1. Brielle September 17, 2009
  2. Brielle September 16, 2009
  3. Leigh September 17, 2009
    • Marti Abernathey September 17, 2009
  4. Leigh September 16, 2009
    • Marti Abernathey September 17, 2009
  5. Katie B. September 17, 2009
    • Marti Abernathey September 17, 2009
      • Katie B. September 17, 2009
  6. Katie B. September 17, 2009
    • Marti Abernathey September 17, 2009
      • Katie B. September 18, 2009
  7. Susan September 17, 2009
    • Marti Abernathey September 17, 2009
  8. Susan September 17, 2009
    • Marti Abernathey September 17, 2009
  9. Kim September 17, 2009
  10. Kim September 17, 2009
  11. Circé September 17, 2009
  12. Circé September 17, 2009
  13. Leigh September 17, 2009
    • Marti Abernathey September 17, 2009
  14. Leigh September 17, 2009
    • Marti Abernathey September 17, 2009
  15. Leigh September 17, 2009
  16. Leigh September 17, 2009
  17. Felix Garnet-Simister September 18, 2009
    • Marti Abernathey September 18, 2009
  18. Felix Garnet-Simister September 17, 2009
    • Marti Abernathey September 18, 2009
  19. aug September 18, 2009
    • Marti Abernathey September 18, 2009
  20. aug September 18, 2009
    • Marti Abernathey September 18, 2009
  21. Leigh September 18, 2009
  22. Leigh September 18, 2009
  23. aug September 18, 2009
  24. aug September 18, 2009
  25. Susan September 18, 2009
    • Marti Abernathey September 18, 2009
  26. Susan September 18, 2009
    • Marti Abernathey September 18, 2009
  27. Susan September 18, 2009
    • Circé September 18, 2009
  28. Susan September 18, 2009
    • Circé September 18, 2009
  29. Susan September 18, 2009
    • Marti Abernathey September 21, 2009
  30. Susan September 18, 2009
    • Marti Abernathey September 21, 2009
  31. Just Jennifer September 18, 2009
  32. Just Jennifer September 18, 2009
  33. javier September 19, 2009
    • Just Jennifer September 19, 2009
    • Marti Abernathey September 21, 2009
  34. javier September 18, 2009
    • Just Jennifer September 19, 2009
    • Marti Abernathey September 21, 2009
  35. javier September 21, 2009
    • Marti Abernathey September 21, 2009
      • Just Jennifer September 21, 2009
        • Marti Abernathey September 21, 2009
          • Just Jennifer September 22, 2009
          • Marti Abernathey September 22, 2009
          • Just Jennifer September 23, 2009
          • Marti Abernathey September 24, 2009
    • Just Jennifer September 21, 2009
  36. javier September 20, 2009
    • Marti Abernathey September 21, 2009
      • Just Jennifer September 21, 2009
        • Marti Abernathey September 21, 2009
          • Just Jennifer September 21, 2009
          • Marti Abernathey September 22, 2009
          • Just Jennifer September 22, 2009
          • Marti Abernathey September 24, 2009
    • Just Jennifer September 21, 2009
  37. Susan September 21, 2009
  38. Susan September 21, 2009
  39. aug September 21, 2009
    • Marti Abernathey September 21, 2009
    • Just Jennifer September 21, 2009
  40. aug September 21, 2009
    • Marti Abernathey September 21, 2009
    • Just Jennifer September 21, 2009
  41. Susan September 21, 2009
  42. Susan September 21, 2009
  43. Leigh September 22, 2009
    • Marti Abernathey September 23, 2009
      • Leigh September 23, 2009
  44. Leigh September 22, 2009
    • Marti Abernathey September 22, 2009
      • Leigh September 22, 2009
  45. Marti Abernathey September 24, 2009
  46. Marti Abernathey September 24, 2009
  47. Just Jennifer September 26, 2009
  48. Just Jennifer September 26, 2009
  49. Just Jennifer September 26, 2009
  50. Soulmates November 11, 2009
    • Just Jennifer November 12, 2009
  51. Soulmates November 11, 2009
  52. Soulmates November 11, 2009
    • Just Jennifer November 12, 2009
  53. Just Jennifer November 12, 2009
  54. Just Jennifer November 12, 2009
  55. Caylin November 16, 2009
  56. Caylin November 16, 2009
  57. Caylin November 16, 2009
  58. nicole February 16, 2013

Add Comment

img_5800e5bd88d8a
Johns Hopkins Resumes Trans Care
DL-art
The New York Magazine lies to parents about trans children
92
The media is lying about why NC is being sued
91
What the US Attorney General actually said about trans people & fighting NC in court
transphobia5
The Politics of Transphobia
img_579a295a28d15
Is Sadism Popular With TERFs? A Chat With An Ex-Gendercrit
chai
EEOC Commissioner: “Contrary state or local laws provide no defense to an employer that violates Title VII”
85
Study: Trans kid’s gender implicit; govt report condemns conversion therapy
95c
The Gill Foundation & NCTE choose money over trans lives
KrellTitle
In Memory of Terri Williams Moore (1941–1976)
87
[Updated] Predatory publishers and their dupes
84
The NY Times goes concern trolling
95c
The Gill Foundation & NCTE choose money over trans lives
transphobia5
The Politics of Transphobia
86
Fight back: Report Mississippi & North Carolina HATE here!
CitizensForResponsiblePolicy_CreepyGuy
The 2008 Gainesville Bathroom Bill TV Spot Revisited